Chapter 6 - The Sons Choose

That evening, Daniel made his biggest mistake yet.
He didn't call me. He waited until Mason's basketball game ended at Upper Arlington High School.
I was sitting in the third row of the bleachers with Tyler. Mason had played brilliantly, scoring fourteen points in a hard-fought win against Dublin Jerome. The gym was emptying, the squeak of sneakers and the echoes of the pep band fading down the hallways.
Mason came out of the locker room, his hair damp from the shower, duffel bag slung over his broad shoulder.
Standing near the double doors, lurking beside the trophy cases like an unwelcome ghost, was Daniel.
He was wearing an overcoat that looked rumpled, his hair unstyled, a desperate, hollow smile plastered on his face.
"Mase!" Daniel called out, stepping into his path. "Great game, buddy. That three-pointer from the corner in the fourth? That was pure money."
Mason stopped dead in his tracks. Tyler stiffened beside me on the bleachers, his jaw clenching. I touched Tyler’s arm, whispering, "Let your brother handle it."
Mason didn't smile. He didn't drop his bag. He stood six-foot-one, looking directly into the eyes of the father he had idolized for sixteen years.
"What are you doing here, Dad?" Mason asked.
"What do you mean?" Daniel chuckled nervously, reaching out to clap Mason on the shoulder. Mason stepped back, letting Daniel’s hand fall through empty air. "I'm your dad. I come to your games. Look, I know things have been... messy. Grown-up stuff. Your mother is being very vindictive right now, but that has nothing to do with us. Come get some dinner with me. Julianna isn't there, I swear. Just you, me, and Ty. Steaks at The Top."
Tyler stood up from the bleachers and walked down the steps, his boots heavy on the wood. He came to stand shoulder-to-shoulder with his younger brother.
"Mom isn't being vindictive, Dad," Tyler said, his voice quiet, cold, and devastatingly mature. "Mom is surviving what you did."
"Tyler, stay out of this," Daniel snapped, his old authoritarian temper flaring for a fraction of a second. "You don't understand the dynamics of adult relationships."
"I understand what an adult does," Mason said, speaking up. His voice shook slightly, but he held his ground. "An adult doesn't tell his wife he's leaving her while she’s basting a turkey for his family. An adult doesn't bring his twenty-six-year-old girlfriend into our house an hour later while the oven is still smoking. You didn't just leave Mom, Dad. You blew up the whole house and expected us to thank you for the fireworks."
Daniel looked between his two sons, panic fluttering behind his eyes. "I made a mistake in the delivery, Mason! I apologized!"
"You didn't apologize," Tyler countered. "You made excuses. You blamed Grandma, you blamed Mom, you blamed stress. You haven't once asked Mason how his finals are going. You haven't asked if I need help with tuition since you froze the joint accounts. You just want us to show up so you don't feel like the villain in your own story."
"I am your father!" Daniel raised his voice, the sound bouncing off the empty gym walls. A few straggling parents turned to stare. "I paid for your schools! I paid for your cars! Everything you have came from me!"
"No," Mason said, stepping past him toward the exit. "It came from Mom. You just signed the checks. Don't come to my games anymore, Dad. Not until you figure out how to be a human being."
Tyler followed his brother without another word.
Daniel stood alone in the hallway under the fluorescent gym lights. He caught sight of me standing at the top of the bleachers. For three seconds, our eyes locked.
I didn't glare. I didn't sneer. I looked at him with complete, untroubled indifference.
May you like
He was the architect of his own exile, and we both knew it.
---