civica

Chapter 10 - Sarah's Desperate Betrayal

At 4:00 PM that afternoon, while the movers were already staging boxes in the lower rooms of Highland Manor, Sarah Vance arrived at my front gates.

She didn't come in her luxury SUV—that had been repossessed three hours earlier from the parking lot of her personal trainer's gym. She arrived in an old, dented rideshare sedan, wearing an oversized trench coat and dark sunglasses to hide her swollen, unwashed face.

My security guard at the gate radioed up to the house.

"Mrs. Vance, your sister is at the gate on foot. She says she has something you need."

I stood on the second-story balcony of Highland Manor, looking down the winding driveway. The bitter winter wind whipped my coat around my legs.

"Let her walk up," I said. "Alone."

It took Sarah fifteen minutes to trudge through the snow-packed driveway in her flimsy designer ankle boots. By the time she reached the heavy oak double doors, her lips were blue, her designer trench coat was spattered with dirty slush, and her teeth were clicking together like dice in a cup.

I stood in the grand foyer, watching her stumble across the threshold. The house around us was echoing, half-empty. The antique paintings of Evelyn’s ancestors had already been taken down, revealing pale, square outlines on the silk wallpaper.

"Claire..." Sarah breathed, wrapping her arms around her chest, shivering so hard she could barely stand. "Please... you have to listen to me."

"You have five minutes, Sarah," I said, checking my wristwatch. "At 4:20, the locksmith finishes rekeying the master wing."

Sarah reached into her deep coat pocket and pulled out a heavy manila envelope, tied with red string. Her hands were raw, chattered by the cold.

"Mom is planning to burn the house down," Sarah whispered, her eyes darting frantically toward the windows.

I raised an eyebrow, keeping my expression entirely flat. "Is that so?"

"Tonight," Sarah stammered, stepping closer, holding the envelope out like an offering to an angry god. "At 2:00 AM. She hired two guys from the marina. They’re bringing accelerants through the lower boathouse tunnel. She’s going to light the basement and claim the insurance money from the secondary policy before the fraud freeze goes through!"

"And what is in the envelope?" I asked.

"The text messages," Sarah cried, tears spilling over her mascara. "The bank transfer receipts from Mom’s personal account to the guys at the marina! The blueprints of the boathouse tunnel with Mom’s handwritten notes marking the gas lines! Everything, Claire! I stole it from her laptop while she was screaming at Dad in the motel room!"

I tilted my head, studying my younger sister.

For twenty years, Sarah had been Evelyn’s attack dog. She had planted stolen jewelry in my high school locker to get me suspended. She had deliberately spilled red wine on my wedding dress minutes before I walked down the aisle.

And now, the moment Evelyn’s ship was beneath the waves, the golden child was serving her own mother up on a silver platter.

"Why are you giving this to me, Sarah?" I asked softly.

Sarah fell to her knees on the marble floor, clutching at the edge of my coat, weeping with pure, unadulterated selfishness.

"Give me the carriage house," she begged, looking up at me with wide, terrified eyes. "Just sign the carriage house over to me, Claire! That’s all I want! It has two bedrooms! I can live there, I can restart my boutique online! I won't ever bother you, I won't ever speak to you again! Just don't let me end up on the streets with Mom and Dad! Please, Claire! I'm your sister!"

I looked down at her.

"You're not my sister, Sarah," I said, my voice steady, merciless, and calm. "You're Arthur’s daughter. The product of the woman who spent twenty-eight years trying to destroy me."

"I didn't know!" Sarah shrieked. "I swear to God, Claire, I didn't know about Margaret until this morning on the news! Mom lied to me too!"

"You didn't need to know about Margaret to treat me like a human being," I replied. "You didn't need to know about the deeds to avoid calling my three-year-old child a deadweight at Christmas dinner."

I reached down and took the manila envelope from her trembling hands.

"Thank you for the evidence," I said. "The Lake County Prosecutor will add attempted arson and conspiracy to Evelyn’s indictment."

Sarah scrambled to her feet, a desperate, hysterical smile breaking through her tears. "So... the carriage house? You’ll tell your lawyers to draw up the deed?"

I walked to the front door, pushed it open, and pointed down the long, freezing driveway.

"The nearest public bus stop is two miles south on Sheridan Road, Sarah," I told her. "If you hurry, you might catch the 4:45."

Sarah’s face went dead white. The realization that her betrayal had bought her nothing hit her like a physical blow.

"You used me!" she screamed, her voice cracking into that familiar, ugly Vance screech. "You took my evidence and you’re throwing me out anyway! You're evil! You're worse than Mom!"

"No, Sarah," I said, looking her up and down one last time. "Mom was a monster who built an empire of lies. You’re just a coward who couldn't even survive twenty-four hours without her allowance."

I signaled the security guard waiting at the bottom of the steps.

"Escort Miss Vance off the property," I ordered. "If she steps past the iron gates again, have her arrested for criminal trespassing."

As Sarah was led down the snow-covered driveway, screaming obscenities into the freezing wind, I closed the heavy oak doors, slid the deadbolt into place, and handed the arson evidence to Mark.

May you like

"Call the Lake County SWAT team," I said. "Let’s make sure Evelyn’s marina friends have a welcoming committee at the boathouse tonight."

***

Related Stories

Other posts