civica

Chapter 8 - The Deposition from Hell

The formal deposition took place ten days later in the fourteenth-floor conference room of Brooks & Associates.

It was a bright, cloudless Tuesday morning. Through the expansive floor-to-ceiling windows, the city of Charlotte stretched out in shimmering glass and steel.

Sitting across from Natalie and me was Grant Vance, flanked by two attorneys: Richard Sterling, who looked as though he had aged ten years in two weeks, and a prominent federal criminal defense lawyer named Marcus Thorne, whom Evelyn had retained at the eye-watering rate of twelve hundred dollars an hour.

Grant was out on bail, but he looked completely diminished.

His expensive suits hung loosely from his frame; he had lost at least fifteen pounds; and his face carried the hollow, gaunt look of a man who spent his nights staring at the ceiling of an extended-stay motel room, realizing that every exit had been blocked. He didn't look at me. He couldn't bring himself to meet my eyes.

A court stenographer sat at the end of the table, her fingers poised over the keys of her machine.

"We are on the record," the stenographer announced. "Deposition of Grant Alexander Vance in the matter of *Vance v. Vance*, Mecklenburg County District Court."

Natalie adjusted her glasses and smoothed a stack of printed exhibits in front of her.

"State your full name and current residential address for the record," Natalie began.

"Grant Alexander Vance," he muttered, his voice barely carrying across the table. "Current address: Room 214, Staybridge Suites, Charlotte Airport."

The humiliation of stating that address out loud was palpable. Grant winced as if he had swallowed glass.

"Mr. Vance," Natalie said, picking up Exhibit 14. "I show you what has been marked as the forensic audit of Apex Holdings LLC and the encrypted digital vault surrendered to the United States Attorney’s Office on Friday. Do you recognize these records?"

Marcus Thorne, the criminal defense attorney, touched Grant’s arm. "On advice of counsel, the witness invokes his Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination."

Natalie didn't miss a beat. "In a civil domestic proceeding in North Carolina, Mr. Thorne, the court is permitted to draw an adverse inference from a party’s invocation of the Fifth Amendment regarding the dissipation of marital assets. We note your invocation for the record."

She turned the page.

"Mr. Vance, between January 2021 and September of this year, did you divert three point two million dollars of income earned during the marriage into foreign bank accounts without the knowledge or consent of your wife?"

Grant’s hands clenched into fists under the mahogany table. He looked at Thorne, who shook his head minutely.

"Fifth," Grant rasped.

"Did you forge your brother Julian Vance’s signature on a four-million-dollar secondary construction guarantee for the Lake Norman development project?"

"Fifth."

"Did you wire fifty thousand dollars of marital funds to an entity owned by your mistress, Tessa Montgomery, on the evening of November 12th, while falsely claiming under oath to this court that you lacked liquidity to pay household utilities?"

"Fifth."

"Did you," Natalie continued, her voice rising in pitch and precision, "repeatedly tell your wife, Grace Vance, that she was legally and financially incompetent, with the explicit intention of preventing her from discovering your systemic financial fraud?"

Grant’s jaw worked violently. A vein throbbed against his left temple. He looked up, his bloodshot eyes locking onto mine for the first time.

"I built that company," he hissed through clenched teeth, ignoring Thorne’s warning grip on his forearm. "I worked eighty hours a week while you sat at home! Everything I did was to secure this family’s future!"

"By moving your mistress into our guest room in front of our children?" I spoke up for the first time.

The conference room went dead silent.

Richard Sterling closed his eyes. Marcus Thorne tapped his pen nervously against his pad.

Grant stared at me, his lip curling into a familiar, venomous sneer. "Tessa was a mistake, Grace! You think you're innocent? You sat there for months playing the quiet, obedient wife while you were stealing my files! You spied on me! You plotted this whole thing! You're a cold, calculating—"

"Mr. Vance!" Natalie’s voice cut through his tirade like a whip. "You will maintain professional decorum in this deposition, or I will terminate this session and immediately file a motion for terminal sanctions with Judge Henderson."

Grant slumped back in his chair, breathing heavily, chest heaving like a wounded beast that had run out of ground.

"Let’s talk about the marital estate, Mr. Vance," Natalie said, sliding a comprehensive settlement proposal across the table toward Richard Sterling.

Sterling picked it up, his eyes scanning the terms. As he read, his eyebrows climbed higher and higher toward his receding hairline.

"Ms. Brooks," Sterling said, his voice strained. "This isn't a settlement. This is total surrender."

"It is an equitable distribution proposal based on cold mathematical reality, Mr. Sterling," Natalie countered. "Here are the terms: Mrs. Vance receives sole legal and physical custody of Owen, Lily, and Maya Vance. Mr. Vance’s parental rights will be subject to supervised visitation only, contingent upon the completion of a comprehensive psychological evaluation and sixty consecutive days of clean drug and alcohol screenings."

Grant looked as if he wanted to scream, but the presence of Marcus Thorne kept him pinned to his seat.

"Second," Natalie continued. "The marital residence at 1442 Highland Crest Way will be sold immediately. The net proceeds, estimated at one point eight million dollars after satisfying the first mortgage, will be awarded entirely to Mrs. Vance to offset the three point two million dollars in marital funds Mr. Vance dissipated through offshore shell entities."

"And what does my client get?" Sterling asked, throwing his hands up in exasperation.

"Your client gets to avoid a civil trial that would expose his entire fraudulent enterprise to every commercial lender in the state of North Carolina," Natalie said flatly. "And Mrs. Vance agrees to allocate twenty-five percent of the net proceeds from the ancillary vehicle sales toward his outstanding federal restitution obligations, preventing him from serving the maximum statutory sentence under the federal sentencing guidelines."

Marcus Thorne leaned toward Grant, whispering intensely in his ear for three straight minutes.

I watched Grant’s face as his criminal defense attorney spoke.

I watched the last remnants of his arrogance crumble. I watched the realization sink in that his mother couldn't save him, his country club connections couldn't save him, and his expensive tailored suits couldn't save him.

He was facing forty-eight to sixty months in a federal minimum-security prison for tax evasion, wire fraud, and bank forgery. The only thing standing between him and a decade behind bars was the cooperation agreement facilitated by the very evidence I had gathered while sitting quietly in his home office at three in the morning.

Finally, Thorne leaned back. "My client will sign."

Grant looked up, his eyes completely hollow. He looked at the signature page of the agreement, then looked across the table at me.

"You really planned this from the very beginning, didn't you?" he whispered, his voice broken, stripped of every trace of the booming patriarch who had ruled our home. "From the day you found that first foreign statement eleven months ago."

I looked at him with steady, clear eyes, feeling the gentle, sleeping weight of Maya in the bassinet beside me.

"I didn't plan your destruction, Grant," I said softly. "You planned that yourself when you decided that loyalty was weakness, that cruelty was power, and that numbers could lie forever."

I stood up, smoothing the front of my dress.

May you like

"I didn't destroy you, Grant. I just balanced the ledger."

***

Related Stories

Other posts