civica

Chapter 4 - The Traitor in White

The fire in the hearth crackled loudly in the silent room.

Ethan slowly turned his head to look at Claire.

Claire was standing frozen near the bookcase. Her mouth was slightly open, her complexion the color of ash.

"Ethan, don't listen to this lunatic," Claire stammered, her hands trembling as she smoothed down her white silk dress. "I don't even know what clinic she's talking about! I met you eighteen months ago! You already had Oliver! Why would I have anything to do with his birth?!"

"Because you didn't meet me eighteen months ago by accident, did you, Claire?" Ethan asked, his voice dropping into a dark, lethal register.

He walked slowly toward her. Ethan was a man who had built a multi-billion-dollar empire by reading people, by spotting lies in boardrooms before they could poison his company. For eighteen months, he had believed Claire was a warm, structured woman who loved his quiet son. Now, looking at her tight posture and panicked eyes, the scales fell from his vision.

"Two years ago, when my wife passed away from cancer, I entered a private surrogacy program," Ethan said, recalling the painful memories. "The agency told me the surrogate had successfully delivered a baby boy in Chicago, but that the mother wished to remain completely anonymous and had left the country immediately."

Ethan stepped closer to Claire, looming over her.

"Who recommended that surrogacy agency to my family lawyer back then, Claire? It was your father’s investment firm."

Claire swallowed hard, backing up until her spine hit the mahogany bookcase. "Ethan... my father's firm handles dozens of agencies! I had nothing to do with it! This maid is making up stories to get a settlement!"

"Then let's test the story," Ethan said coldly.

He pulled his smartphone from his pocket and dialed a direct line. He placed the call on speakerphone.

After two rings, a gravelly voice answered. "Ethan? Is everything alright? How is the engagement party?"

It was Dr. Marcus Aris, Ethan’s long-time family physician and the director of the private medical board that had verified Oliver’s birth records two years ago.

"Marcus," Ethan said, his eyes never leaving Claire’s terrified face. "I need you to pull up the original, unredacted DNA profile and birth certificate for Oliver Hawthorne from the Chicago archive."

There was a sudden, sharp pause on the other end of the line.

"Ethan... those records are sealed under high-level confidentiality," Dr. Aris said, his voice suddenly sounding tense. "Why would you need those tonight?"

"Because the woman who gave birth to my son is sitting in my study," Ethan said softly. "And she claims Claire Whitmore paid your clinic to tell her the baby was dead."

A loud, sharp gasp came through the phone speaker, followed by the sound of papers frantically shuffling.

"Ethan, listen to me carefully," Dr. Aris stammered, his professional demeanor evaporating. "Do not do anything rash! Claire’s family... they assured me—"

Ethan cut the call off instantly.

He dropped the phone onto the desk.

The silence in the room was absolute.

Claire dropped her head into her hands, letting out a ragged, hysterical breath. She didn't try to deny it anymore.

"Why?" Ethan asked, his voice shaking with a terrifying mixture of rage and heartbreak. "Why would you do this, Claire?"

Claire slowly lifted her head. The gentle, delicate woman Ethan thought he was going to marry was gone. In her place stood a cold, calculating stranger.

"Because you were grieving, Ethan!" Claire spat, her voice dripping with venom. "You were the richest eligible bachelor in the country, but you were obsessed with having a child to carry the Hawthorne name! My father’s firm was going under. We needed the Hawthorne merger! If I brought you the healthy baby boy you desperately wanted, I knew you would let me into your life!"

She pointed furiously at Elena.

"She was just a poor, nobody college student who came into a public clinic!" Claire sneered. "She couldn't afford to raise a Hawthorne child! I gave that doctor fifty thousand dollars to clean up the records! I saved that baby from a life of poverty!"

A quiet, soft voice spoke from the fireplace.

"I didn't come to a clinic to sell my baby," Elena said, standing up gently while holding Oliver against her chest. "I was sick with preeclampsia. I trusted those doctors. You stole my child from my arms while I was unconscious."

Oliver looked up at Elena, reached his small hand up, and wiped a tear from her cheek.

"Mama," Oliver whispered again, his little voice clear and sweet. "No cry."

Ethan felt a tear slip down his own face. He looked at his son—the boy who had spent two years locked in silent trauma because his spirit knew he was living surrounded by the woman who had stolen him from his real mother.

Ethan turned back to Claire.

"Frank!" Ethan yelled toward the door.

The heavy oak door swung open instantly. Ethan’s chief of security, a massive former Secret Service agent, stepped into the room.

"Yes, Mr. Hawthorne?"

"Take Miss Whitmore to the holding room downstairs," Ethan ordered coldly. "Call the State Police and the FBI human trafficking division. Give them full access to our estate security footage and Dr. Aris’s phone call."

"Ethan, no! You can't do this to me!" Claire screamed as Frank grabbed her arms, pinning them behind her back. "My father will destroy your board! You'll be ruined!"

May you like

"Get her out of my sight," Ethan growled.

Claire’s shrieks echoed down the long marble hallway as Frank dragged her away, the heavy oak doors closing once more into peaceful silence.

Related Stories

Other posts