Chapter 3 - The Feast of the Blind
Three miles away, inside the warm, pine-scented belly of 44 Elmridge Lane, laughter clinked alongside crystal stemware.
The dining room table—a sprawling slab of French oak that could seat twenty—was littered with the remnants of an eight-course feast. Bone china plates smeared with lingonberry reduction and prime rib fat sat before eight people: my father Richard, my mother Eleanor, my older sister Dana, her husband Greg, their fourteen-year-old son Logan, and two distant cousins from Eleanor’s side of the family who owned a yacht charter in Tampa.
Eleanor was holding her glass of chardonnay up toward the chandelier, admiring the golden hue against the crystal drops.
“I must say, Richard,” Eleanor purred, smoothing her silk blouse, “the rib roast was perfection this year. Simply sublime.”
“Told you the butcher down on Fourth was better than the supermarket,” Richard said, loosening his crimson silk tie. At sixty-one, my father carried himself like an English lord who had inherited an empire, rather than a former mid-level VP whose lifestyle had been continuously propped up by his mother’s quarterly distributions. “A bit cramped in here, though. Dana, did Greg ever get that patio heater running?”
“The pilot light went out, Dad,” Dana said, rolling her eyes as she scrolled through her phone, checking the engagement numbers on the family photo she’d posted two hours earlier. The caption read: *Surrounded by love, warmth, and the best family on earth! #blessed #christmasperfection*.
Naturally, Emma was not in the picture.
“Well, it’s a good thing we trimmed the guest list down,” Eleanor said, taking a delicate sip of wine. Her voice dipped into that conspiratorial, self-satisfied tone she used when she felt she had successfully averted a social disaster. “I mean, Kate really ought to know better. Dropping Emma off unannounced with a bag of cheap toys when we clearly said space was limited.”
“She was invited, Eleanor,” Richard muttered, though there was no defense in his tone—only a mild, dismissive boredom. “You sent the card three weeks ago.”
“That was a formality, Richard! Everyone knows Christmas dinner requires an RSVP four days in advance for the caterer. And look at Logan—he needs room to breathe. The boy had hockey practice all morning.”
Logan, slouched in a plush velvet armchair at the end of the table with AirPods shoved into his ears, snorted without looking up from his iPad. “Her dress looked like something from a thrift bin. It had this giant bow on the back like an apron. I told her she looked like a waitress. Aunt Dana laughed.”
“I did not laugh, Logan,” Dana lied smoothly, flashing her mother a conspiratorial smirk. “I simply observed that Kate’s sense of children’s fashion has remained tragically stuck in 2008. And really, bringing those homemade ornaments? Glued felt and glitter? On my mother’s Norwegian spruce? It would have ruined the entire aesthetic of the living room.”
Eleanor waved her hand dismissively. “It’s fine. Kate probably picked her up five minutes after she left the porch. They live just down the boulevard. They’re likely having pizza and watching reruns of whatever dreadful reality show Kate watches. She prefers that low-effort lifestyle anyway. If Kate wanted a seat at an Elmridge table, she should have finished her master’s instead of settling for that clinic job.”
“To family,” Greg said, raising his glass with a chuckle. “And to knowing your limits.”
The glasses chimed together—a bright, crystalline ring that echoed off the high vaulted ceilings of the great room. The roaring stone fireplace sent embers dancing up the flue. The Norwegian spruce, towering twelve feet tall and dripping with five thousand dollars worth of custom platinum and crystal ornaments, cast a warm, hypnotic glow across the polished oak floorboards.
Then, the doorbell rang.
It was not the cheerful, melodic chime of a holiday guest. It was three heavy, rattling blows that made the brass knocker hammer against the solid walnut slab of the double front doors.
Richard frowned, pausing with his fork halfway to his mouth. “Expecting someone else, Eleanor?”
“Certainly not. The carolers finished at five.”
“Maybe it’s the florist delivering the centerpiece for Boxing Day,” Dana suggested, standing up and brushing breadcrumbs from her cashmere trousers. “I’ll get it.”
She stepped out into the foyer, her designer heels clicking sharply on the imported Italian slate. The dining room fell quiet, listening to the muffled scrape of the deadbolt sliding back.
A moment later, Dana’s voice drifted back to the dining room—not her usual high-pitched, performative cadence, but tight, breathless, and sharp with irritation.
“Sheriff Miller? What on earth... is there an issue on the road?”
Richard stood up, his face hardening into that pompous scowl he reserved for service workers and municipal employees. “Miller? What’s Bob Miller doing here on Christmas?”
He strode out of the dining room into the bright chandelier light of the foyer, Eleanor trailing closely behind him, her linen napkin still clutched in one manicured hand.
Standing on the front porch, framed by the falling snowflakes and the biting black wind, stood Sheriff Robert Miller in his full winter service jacket, his Stetson dusted with frost. Beside him stood a clean-shaven man in a tailored charcoal wool overcoat holding an embossed leather portfolio: Arthur Vance.
May you like
And standing right behind Arthur, wrapped in a black trench coat with her eyes burning like twin crucibles, was me.
***
